Wagner Cast Iron Griddle – 1950 Vintage Reissue in Wooden Box – Double Burner Griddle for Stovetop & Outdoor Cooking – Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron – Handcrafted in USA – Naturally Nonstick
Kitchen

Wagner Cast Iron Griddle – 1950 Vintage Reissue in Wooden Box – Double Burner Griddle for Stovetop & Outdoor Cooking – Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron – Handcrafted in USA – Naturally Nonstick

Wagner Cast Iron Skillet

Forged
Forged
$239.00Typical: $50-200 (used)Confidence: high
4.8(33 reviews)

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

About This Product

  • Authentic 1950 Wagner Vintage Reissue: This cast iron griddle is a faithful re-creation of Wagner’s iconic 1950 long griddle. Built using original specifications and traditional sand-casting techniques, it pays tribute to American cast iron heritage while delivering the quality and performance modern kitchens demand. Packaged in a keepsake wooden box, this griddle is a true collector’s piece and everyday cooking essential.
  • Double Burner Design for Versatile Cooking: With a cooking surface of 16⅜" x 8¾" and a total size of 19⅞" x 9⅞" x ¾", this double burner cast iron griddle gives you plenty of room to cook for a crowd. Perfect for pancakes, bacon, burgers, grilled sandwiches, eggs, and more. Its excellent heat retention and even heat distribution ensures consistently great results whether indoors or outdoors.
  • Handcrafted in the USA Using Traditional Methods: Proudly made in the United States, this Wagner griddle is cast and finished by hand using the same time-honored methods as the originals. Each piece reflects the high standards of American-made cookware—durable, reliable, and built to last. We honor the history of cast iron craftsmanship to bring you a piece that’s functional, beautiful, and steeped in tradition.
  • Naturally Seasoned and Made to Last a Lifetime: Pre-seasoned with non-GMO oils for a natural, easy-release surface that improves with use. This griddle is made with pure cast iron—no synthetic coatings or additives—offering safe, long-lasting performance. Weighing 9 lbs, it's sturdy, resistant to warping, and built to be handed down through the generations.
  • Smart Functional Features & Timeless Design: Thoughtfully designed with a grooved edge to catch grease and drippings, raised side handles for easy lifting, and a hanging hole for convenient storage. Whether you're searing on the stove or flipping pancakes at the campsite, this vintage-inspired cast iron griddle blends classic style with everyday functionality for all your cooking needs.

Why It Lasts

Wagner Ware skillets (pre-1999, especially pre-1960) were machine-polished to a glass-smooth cooking surface — something modern Lodge doesn't do. The casting quality and iron composition from the Sidney, Ohio foundry produced thinner, lighter pans that still retained heat beautifully. Collectors and cooks on r/castiron regularly prefer these over any modern production skillet. A well-maintained Wagner from the 1940s performs better than a brand-new pan.

Known Weaknesses

Only available used, which means condition varies wildly — warped bottoms, pitting from rust damage, and heat damage are common finds. Identifying authentic Wagner requires learning foundry markings (lots of fakes and misattributions). The thinner walls that make them lighter also make them more prone to cracking from thermal shock than thick modern Lodge pans. No warranty since the original company is long gone.

Durability Breakdown

Warranty
10.0
Materials
9.5
Community
9.2
Brand Rep
9.5
Repairability
5.3

Specifications

MaterialCast Iron
ColorBrown
Item Weight9 pounds
Product Dimensions19.88"L x 9.88"W x 0.75"Th
ShapeRectangular
Has Nonstick CoatingYes
Recommended Uses For Productcooking pancakes, bacon, burgers, grilled sandwiches, eggs, stovetop cooking, outdoor cooking
Is Dishwasher SafeNo

Data Source

View community discussion →

Quick Stats

Overall Score8.9/10
TierForged
BrandWagner
CategoryKitchen
Price Range$50-200 (used)
Confidencehigh
Data Points5/5
4.8(33 reviews)

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More in Kitchen

Kitchen

Mauviel M'Héritage Copper Saucepan

2.5mm thick copper body — the thickest copper cookware in wide commercial production — with a tin-lined or stainless steel interior. Copper conducts heat 30 times better than stainless steel, which means incredibly fast and responsive temperature changes. The brass handles are cast (not stamped) and brazed to the pan body. Mauviel has made copper cookware in Villedieu-les-Poêles, Normandy since 1830 — the town has been the copper cookware capital of France for 700 years. These pans are bought once and passed down; professional French kitchens use Mauviel for sauces.

Warranty
7.5
communitySentiment
7.3
Repairability
7.3
$200-600Ironclad
Wusthof WU5558 Kitchen Shears, 8", Black
Kitchen

Wusthof WU5558 Kitchen Shears, 8", Black

Forged from a single piece of X50CrMoV15 high-carbon stainless steel — the same bar stock heated, forged, and finish-ground in Solingen, Germany. The full bolster (the thick metal collar between blade and handle) adds weight, balance, and prevents the blade from rocking into the handle. The triple-riveted polyoxymethylene (POM) handle resists fading, cracking, and moisture absorption better than wood or composite alternatives. Wusthof's Precision Edge Technology grinds the blade at 14 degrees per side (versus the traditional 20 degrees), giving it a sharper factory edge. Free lifetime sharpening through authorized retailers.

Warranty
7.5
communitySentiment
7.3
Repairability
7.3
$100-180Ironclad
Kitchen

Staub Cocotte Dutch Oven

Staub's interior enamel is matte black — a rougher texture that promotes browning and seasoning over time, unlike Le Creuset's glossy cream interior. Each Cocotte is cast individually at Staub's Alsace foundry using a sand mold that's destroyed after each pour — no two pieces are exactly alike. The self-basting spikes on the lid interior channel condensation uniformly back onto food, improving moisture retention in braises. The cast iron body retains heat evenly for up to 30 minutes after removing from heat. Staub comes with a lifetime warranty.

communitySentiment
8.2
Repairability
7.8
Warranty
7.6
$250-400Ironclad