No image available

Tools

Starrett Combination Square

Ironclad
Ironclad
Typical: $80-150Confidence: medium

Why It Lasts

Starrett squares are precision-machined in Athol, Massachusetts to tolerances of ±0.0001 inch. The blade is hardened and ground stainless steel with graduations engraved and filled (not printed) — they cannot wear off. The cast iron head is machined flat and square to within fractions of a thousandth of an inch. Unlike the Chinese-made squares sold at hardware stores, a Starrett square is accurate enough to use for precision machining setups. The center-finding and protractor heads are interchangeable on the same blade. These tools are passed from machinist to machinist across careers; Starrett has made them since 1880.

Known Weaknesses

At $80-150 for a combination square, this is significantly more expensive than the $15-30 alternatives that are accurate enough for rough carpentry. The precision is overkill for anything other than metalworking, fine woodworking, or cabinetmaking. The hardened stainless blade can still develop surface rust in very humid environments if not kept oiled. The lock nut on the head can loosen if the square is dropped — it needs periodic retightening. Not readily available at big-box hardware stores.

Durability Breakdown

Warranty
7.5
materials
6.7
communitySentiment
7.3
brandReputation
6.9
Repairability
7.3

Data Source

View community discussion →

Quick Stats

Overall Score77.0/10
TierIronclad
BrandStarrett
CategoryTools
Price Range$80-150
Confidencemedium
Data Points/5

More in Tools

Tools

Estwing Estwing Framing Hammer

Forged from a single piece of American steel — head and handle are one continuous piece, not joined by a wedge or epoxy. This eliminates the primary failure mode of wooden-handle hammers (handle separation) entirely. Made in Rockford, Illinois since 1923. The polished face is hardened to resist mushrooming on framing nails. The nylon vinyl grip is shock-absorbing without being a mechanical component — it can be replaced with bare steel if damaged. Professional framers and carpenters on r/Construction and r/BuyItForLife report using the same Estwing for 20-30 year careers.

Repairability
9.1
Warranty
8.7
communitySentiment
8.1
$35-60Ironclad
Tools

Fiskars X27 Super Splitting Axe

The X27's handle is injection-molded FiberComp — a fiberglass and resin composite that is stronger than wood grain-for-grain and will not warp, split, or absorb water. The head is drop-forged steel hardened to a full convex profile that forces wood fibers apart efficiently rather than cutting through them. The proprietary convex edge geometry is more effective than flat-ground axes at splitting wood because it drives the crack through the grain rather than cutting it. Fiskars backs the X27 with a lifetime warranty covering defects and breakage. The material literally cannot rot or warp — the handle will outlast any owner.

Warranty
8.7
communitySentiment
8.5
Repairability
7.9
$50-80Ironclad
Tools

Klein Tools Journeyman Lineman's Pliers

Drop-forged from US steel and induction-hardened at the cutting edge — the jaw faces are hardened to a different rockwell than the body, giving you a tool that cuts hardened copper wire while maintaining a shock-resistant body that won't crack. Klein has been the standard-issue pliers for US electricians since 1857 and is still made in Mansfield, Illinois. The 9-inch model handles up to 6-gauge solid and 8-gauge stranded wire in its side cutter. The insulated handle versions are ASTM and UL tested to 1,000V AC — real working electrical safety rating, not decorative rubber.

Warranty
7.5
communitySentiment
7.3
Repairability
7.3
$25-60Ironclad