No image available

Footwear

Frye Frye Campus 14L Boot

Ironclad
Ironclad
Typical: $350-500Confidence: medium

Why It Lasts

The Campus boot uses Frye's Antique-Pull-Up leather — a full-grain cattlehide that's drum-stuffed with oils and waxes at the tannery, making it naturally water-resistant from the fiber level rather than relying on topical treatments. The harness stitching is tripled — three passes of waxed thread through the heavy leather — and uses a saddle stitch pattern that, unlike lockstitch, only unravels one stitch at a time if cut. Frye has been making boots in the US since 1863, and the Campus is their heritage workhorse. The Goodyear welt allows resoling.

Known Weaknesses

Frye quality has declined since the company was acquired by Global Brands Group (2012) and then went through bankruptcy (2019). Current production no longer carries the full American-made quality of vintage Frye. The Women's boot line maintains better reviews than the Men's. The leather is soft and beautiful but dents and creases more visibly than harder pull-up leathers from Red Wing. The leather sole on some Campus models is slippery — have a cobbler add a rubber half-sole immediately upon purchase.

Durability Breakdown

Warranty
7.5
materials
6.7
communitySentiment
7.3
brandReputation
6.9
Repairability
7.3

Data Source

View community discussion →

Quick Stats

Overall Score77.0/10
TierIronclad
BrandFrye
CategoryFootwear
Price Range$350-500
Confidencemedium
Data Points/5

More in Footwear

Footwear

Thorogood American Heritage 6-Inch Moc Toe Boot

Built in Merrill, Wisconsin on a Goodyear Storm Welt — a welt variant that wraps around the entire perimeter including the heel, making these even more resoleable than a standard welt. The upper uses full-grain American leather on a single-density Poron XRD foam footbed over a fiberglass shank. The MAXWear Wedge outsole is a dense Vibram compound that wears slower than crepe or standard rubber. Thorogood has been making work boots since 1892 and these are consistently recommended by tradespeople on r/workboots and r/BuyItForLife.

brandReputation
8.5
Warranty
8.1
communitySentiment
8.1
$190-260Ironclad
Footwear

Thursday Boot Company Captain Boot

Goodyear welted with full-grain Cavalier leather from Italian tanneries — the welt allows resoling by any competent cobbler. The nylon midsole threads through a metal shank for arch support. The Dainite rubber sole is a studded British-made compound that wears extremely slowly and provides grip on wet surfaces without appearing obviously outdoor. At $200, Thursday offers most of the construction quality of boots costing twice as much by eliminating the retail markup through direct-to-consumer sales.

brandReputation
8.4
materials
8.2
Repairability
8.2
$180-250Ironclad
Footwear

Oak Street Bootmakers Trail Oxford

Handstitched in Chicago using Horween Natural Chromexcel leather — a chrome-tanned, combination-retanned leather that is the most water-resistant and patina-developing leather available in American production. The chain stitch construction bonds the sole to the upper without adhesive, making it fully rebuildable. The Vibram Roccia sole is a thin City vibram designed for pavement that can be replaced. OSB's repair program replaces soles and refinishes leather on any boot they've made. The trail oxford has been a consistent r/malefashionadvice and r/goodyearwelt recommendation for a decade.

Warranty
8.6
materials
7.6
Repairability
7.4
$345-450Ironclad